There’s a good argument to be made that a classic country song should be comfortable, not challenging. Of all the modern music genres, country maintains perhaps the strongest ties to its origins — folk music, the music of the people, a humble reflection of everyday life. A mere few chords, a simple melody, and relatable, yet profound, lyrics can be all that’s needed to create a true country standard. The comfort of it is the point, and the value. Shana Feste’s Heartland strives for maximum comfort, and achieves it, but where it possesses the mere few chords, the simple storyline, and the relatability, it lacks the profundity to achieve much more. Its familiarity feels appropriate, but as a mystery thriller, it’s predictability hobbles it, turning an easy watch into a rather strained one. Despite a reliably committed performance from Jessica Chastain, it’s a largely disposable movie, likely destined to become just a footnote in the careers of most involved.

Chastain plays Misty Jones, a former country music singer now living a quiet, solitary life on a farm in Georgia. Hard-headed and embittered, she holds no intentions of returning to the spotlight. But when her niece, Charlie (Carter Faith), a rising star in Nashville, goes missing, she agrees to poke her head around the city in search for clues. Accompanied by record label owner Roy Combs (Garrett Hedlund) and aided by her own notoriety, she gains plenty of access but uncovers few answers at first — the police stonewall her, and old industry colleagues are unwilling to rebuild the bridges she’s burnt. Misty isn’t one to take no for an answer, however, and raises enough hell to get the attention not only of police and industry figures, but of the whole world, making Charlie’s disappearance public and generally causing so much trouble you may wonder if her strategy wasn’t to scare the truth out of people. Feste has written Misty as a classic avenging angel, all force and fury, though her indefatigable determination mostly comes off as convenience — there’s an inevitability to Heartland, since you’re never in any doubt that Misty will succeed, even if it’s at any possible cost.

Chastain does an excellent job at making such an extreme character feel believable, even if some of the movie’s broader strokes conflict with her impassioned intensity. But Misty’s zeal still feels out of place, despite an early twist and some hackneyed backstory lending it some legitimacy. That she’d devote herself so wholeheartedly to finding her niece simply never rings true, and it exposes a lack of thematic exploration in Heartland. Feste has a few things to say about the predatory, often misogynistic, nature of the entertainment industry, but they’re so underdeveloped as to be only window dressing for the plot — and it’s too thin a plot to sustain itself independently. Yet there’s also lot to be admired about Heartland, and it arises from Feste’s care in depicting that industry. Too many movies about media — be it music, cinema, TV, theatre, whatever — fail to convince in their depictions; Heartland is guilty of this too, albeit briefly, in a few scenes featuring TV shows that bear little resemblance to recognizable TV broadcasts. But the movie’s milieu is mostly, and gratifyingly, accurate — a couple of live performances are very well staged, and the soundtrack is terrific. As in Feste’s Country Strong, her 2010 movie with which Heartland shares many similarities, the lay listener would have a tough time discerning the cover versions with the original tracks performed here — there’s considerable care and love put into faithfully recreating this scene.

That care is an integral part to the comfort of this movie, so it’s a shame that it hasn’t been extended to other elements. Feste settles into that comfort — which worked better in Country Strong — which proves dissonant to the mystery element here, which thrives on instilling discomfort in the viewer. Everything is also distractingly spelled out — characters introduced in full by name before their first appearance — and everyone is either exactly who they appear to be or as you suspect they’ll turn out to be. There’s no suspense, and no variation in pace or tone either, so the film is left to merely amble forward to a conclusion you could have forecast within the first few minutes. A little more challenge, and a lot less comfort, and Heartland might have at least been memorable.

DIRECTOR: Shana Feste;  CAST: Jessica Chastain, Carter Faith, Ross Lynch, John Hawkes, Garrett Hedlund;  DISTRIBUTOR: Netflix;  STREAMING: November 13;  RUNTIME: 1 hr. 54 min.

Comments are closed.