This critic should disclose, right up top, that his grandmother is among the exploited viewers of Jim Bakker and the various iterations of his televangelist empire, having given thousands of dollars to the church/network/regime several decades ago. But any potential for bias in this review is irrelevant when all roads lead to bullshit. Primetime Preacher$ understands this, and comprehensively draws on archival footage and knowledgeable talking heads to deliver an at-times engrossing, but mostly overlong, overly safe, and unnovel account of the televisual Holy Wars.
In Kevin Howley’s article “Prey TV,” he sharply critiques the permeation of these “electronic churches” and the agendas they tout into all areas of civic life, from households to schools to the courts to the political arena. Since the piece’s publication in 2001, primetime television has dwindled in prominence, fracturing and taking new shape across other forms of media — a documentary exploring this dimension, tapping into not just the televangelism industry’s foundations but also its reverberations into immediate contemporaneity, would have been a lot more fascinating than what Joe Berlinger’s latest presents us with. Instead, we get only hints of sociopolitical inquiry as it digs itself further into the weeds of the inter/intra-congregation feuds, mishandlings of money, personal struggles behind the scenes, and scandals of all persuasions. In other words, nothing we haven’t already been exposed to from loads of other content on this exact same subject, and resultantly, the runtime (just under two hours) really starts to exert its weight; one wonders at a certain point whether it would have been more effective to simply rewatch John Oliver’s brilliant segment on televangelists and “seed faith.” Or, if one dares, an actual episode of one of Bakker’s programs — a particular segment from the late 2010s that this critic has shown to students for the sake of rhetorical analysis is a mind-boggling scheme to sell “Doomsday food buckets” in the face of “civil war” and “anti-Trump rioting” descending on society. Giant, overpriced vats of slop to save you from the big, mean Black Lives Matter activists.
Some of the worthwhile archival moments lingered on here include an interview between Bakker and Ronald Reagan, Tammy Faye’s tender interview with a gay pastor who was diagnosed with AIDS, and, well, really anything involving Tammy Faye. Where the focus gets muddled is when the film incessantly regurgitates salacious details of Bakker’s life and career, his oneupmanship of his competitors, the money laundering and fraud, and all the tabloid-worthy anecdotes that we could easily derive from a reference source. Primetime Preacher$’ greatest sin, in fact, is bearing such a title when in reality it abandons all interesting avenues of study to mainly focus on Jim Bakker and not much else. As Howley urges, “[we] should take greater notice of the cultural dynamics at work in, and the ideological functions of, televangelism,” and interrogate how “religious television is much more than a cultural curiosity… [because it represents the merging of] the church and the media into a daunting, and highly influential, ideological tool.” One would expect a director as versatile as Berlinger, responsible for enduring work like Paradise Lost: The Child Murders at Robin Hood Hills, strange artifacts like Book of Shadows: Blair Witch 2, and a slew of exhaustive documentaries over the years, to have dipped further into the thorny side of televangelism as that sort of “ideological tool” or a political apparatus unto itself — or even just to bathe for longer segments in the idiosyncratic mania of their programming. Yet he quickly drops those lenses to build toward what is mostly a Netflix-ified account of infighting, true crime-style scheming, and sordid affairs — streaming-equipped background fodder that proves more exhausting than exhaustive when viewed attentively, notepad in-hand, review in-mind. In hindsight, maybe some laundry folding could have been done in tandem, perhaps even enhanced the experience.
DIRECTOR: Joe Berlinger; DISTRIBUTOR: Netflix; STREAMING: November 20; RUNTIME: 1 hr. 53 min.
![Primetime Preacher$ — Joe Berlinger [Review] Televangelist in red robe raises fist beside blonde woman in pink holding a microphone under a stained-glass ON AIR sign.](https://inreviewonline.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/primetimepreachers-poster-768x434.jpg)
Comments are closed.